From the Rebuilding Native Nations Course Series: "Test: Does Your Nation Have an Independent Judiciary?"

Native Nations Institute

Professor Robert A. Williams, Jr. shares a short test to help a Native nation and its leaders and citizens determine whether or not their judicial system is truly independent.

Native Nations

Williams, Jr., Robert A. "Justice Systems: Moving Your Nation Forward." Native Nations Institute for Leadership, Management, and Policy, University of Arizona. Tucson, Arizona. 2012. Lecture.

"So, like Miriam, I'm going to ask you to take a test to see whether or not you have an independent judiciary on your reservation. Get out your pens, check yes or no, and we'll tally at the end:

On my reservation, the Chair is related to the Chief Justice -- yes or no?

On my reservation, the Chair is poker buddies with the Chief Justice.

On my reservation, judicial review means the Council can review any judge who makes an unpopular decision and fire him.

On my reservation, checks and balances are something the tribal finance office can’t keep track of.

On my reservation, separation of powers means the Council doesn't ask questions about the judiciary's travel expenses, and the judiciary doesn't ask questions about the Council's.

On my reservation, the question of whether the tribe has waived its sovereign immunity is something that only the Council can decide.

Now, if you had six to five "no's" you are very independent, but if you only had one to two, it's kangaroo court city, babe. Where do you stand on that test? And as tribal leaders, you need to engage honestly with this issue of, 'Are you ready for an independent and strong tribal judiciary?'" 

Related Resources


Rae Nell Vaughn, former Chief Justice of the Mississippi Choctaw Supreme Court, discusses how justice systems are critical to Native nations' exercise of sovereignty, and sets out some key things that those systems need to have in place in order to administer justice fairly and effectively on…

Judge: Tribal courts can incorporate culture, but need independence, due process

Tribal courts on the nation’s Indian reservations must make due process of law and independence hallmarks of their justice system, U.S. District Judge Ralph Erickson told a gathering of judges and other tribal court personnel in Grand Forks Thursday. Tribes can and should incorporate such Indian…

Report on Best Practices in Developing Effective Processes of American Indian Constitutional Reform

The Executive Session on American Indian Constitutional Reform is a national working group of constitutional reformers from 12 American Indian nations and leading academics. The Executive Session meets twice a year to rethink strategies for strengthening tribal constitutions and constitution-making…